Last December, the SEC filed a lawsuit against Ripple (XRP) Labs for alleged unregistered sale of securities. The company made two important defenses in retaliation. One of these defenses was “fair notice affirmative defense”.
But the regulator has now moved to refute Ripple’s fair warning defense. As previously reported, the SEC claimed that the defense in question was “legally” unsuccessful. In the SEC letter, Ripple’s entire defense is in Upton v. He claimed it revolved around the SEC lawsuit. Additionally, the agency also claimed that Upton never filed to dismiss violations in an SEC district court case, and that no court had allowed Upton’s defense to refute the SEC’s legal violation charges.
The SEC ultimately sought to separate the Upton case from the ongoing litigation. He argued that a fair denunciation defense could not be applied in this way. Attorney Jerney Hogan said:
SEC – Kik Interactive Inc. Using his case as a precedent, the SEC continued by emphasizing that Judge Hellerstein “wisely dismissed” the defendants’ Upton defense. Commenting on the possibility of the SEC’s motion being upheld by the court, Hogan said:
Additionally, it’s worth noting that the SEC has been trying to capitalize on the Kik Interactive case since day one. The firm had an ICO in 2017 and was sued on similar grounds as Ripple. Judge Hellerstein, who didn’t know much about technology at the time, decided that Kik’s crypto sales were illegal securities sales. The lawyer continued:
Further explaining why the fair warning defense is important, Hogan claimed that if Ripple wins the fair warning defense, other crypto firms that may be sued in the future will also benefit from it.
It is worth noting here that even if Ripple loses their fair warning defense, they can further appeal the decision. If the appeals court finds that Judge Torres was wrong and Ripple did not give fair notice, things will go badly for the SEC, and this decision will be binding on all future cryptocurrency lawsuits. Hogan concluded his words as follows:
Hello there! My name is Oktay from Tokensboss editors. I introduce myself as a business graduate and writer. I have been doing research on cryptocurrencies and new business lines for over 2 years.